There are loads of myths and folklore bouncing around about mental health and capacity law as well as its interface with criminal law. There are a number of zombie-facts which just refuse to die, for some reason, no matter how many times they’re explained in case law, Preventing Future Deaths reports or public inquiries. I’ve written about a number of these things on this website, we’ve seen lawyers who teach mental health law making public statements about things like this and still, despite all of that, these things refuse to die.
At a recent inquest, a series of discussions took place about whether section 136 MHA could be used in a particular circumstance. I intend to write specifically about that shortly, so suffice to say here the answer was “yes – it can be used in that circumstance.” We’ve known it can be used since 2017 when the law was changed and because when the College of Policing produced informal guidance on the topic for all police forces at their request, not at College insistence. I know this because I had to write the guidance and get it legally checked before emailing it to all force mental health leads in England and Wales to make sure forces were all on the same page.
And yet here we are, an inquest conclusion pending where this was a relevant point of discussion in respect of three deaths and the evidence given at the inquest showed those involved in the decisions just did not know the correct answer. Bearing in mind any question which could be answered “yes” or “no” is one where you’d get it correct about half the time by just flipping a coin, it’s quite the achievement to get it wrong when it’s should be intuitive, borne of experience in managing risk and something which has been explained in guidance to police forces who should be training and leading their staff.
OTHER EXAMPLES
There are loads of other examples, however – Barrister Alex Ruck-Keene KC had to say something fairly pointed to say about the ongoing use of the legal term “capacity” as anything which is relevant to making investigation and prosecution decisions in criminal law. It’s not. It never was. Yet here we are, with public inquiries having to point this out because we know that senior detectives running murder inquiries are talking freely about “capacity” in criminal investigations as if it means something specific – it doesn’t. It never did.
In some recent CPD, mental health leads in acute trusts were telling me about a trend in London of police delivering patients who are AWOL under the Mental Health Act to Emergency Departments and just dropping them off there, after mental health units declined to receive them back. We know this has been going on for a while, I’ve written about it before – but it’s not legal.
The power under s18 MHA (to re-detain an AWOL patient) is a power to return the person to the hospital from which they are missing or to which they have been recalled. Of the various professionals listed in s18(1) MHA who can exercise coercive authority over AWOL powers to force their return, clinical and security staff in EDs are not amongst them.
PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY
Ultimately, police forces tend to take the view that it’s for individual officers to keep up to date with the law and that’s a lazy position for them to take – most of them declined to deliver mental health training to officers which was a mandatory requirement of the Crisis Care Concordat (2014) and MH law training has really fallen off since the police outsourced much of their training to universities on College of Policing accredited degree programmes.
I saw a PowerPoint from an established policing degree programme a few years ago which was so bad, it caused me to stop using my old, worn-out joke about how half of the four hours training I received was wrong and how the other half didn’t work in the real world because the world doesn’t look like the Mental Health Act Code of Practice.
But pushing personal responsiblity, whilst it’s obviously true to an extent, is missing the point. I can sit here banging on about mental health law, as if it’s just a question of people keeping themselves up to date (or reading award-winning blogs in lieu of training!) but the reality is, I can’t say I was always fully up to date about areas of law which changed during my service, outside this specialism – I know I’m not always right about aspects of law within my specialism!
LEADERSHIP
So leaders need to lead – if you want officers to get it right about matters which history shows can end in a death-after-police contact where you’re pilloried, you might need to ensure joint protocols, legally accurate force policies and training for officers as well as quick-access guidance materials. We do this for other areas of policing, I’ve always been at a loss to understand why we don’t do it for mental health and this blog exists because I decided to try and plug that gap when it became obvious no-one was going to do anything about it.
If, as RCRP suggests, the police want to push back appropriately on mental health related demand, they will need to understand the topic sufficiently to know when and how to push back. Of course, given that we know they don’t, we might have to reach our own conclusions as to why.
Perhaps this is as good as it gets and it goes wrong for individual forces so infrequently, they just decide to ride out the storm, knowing investigation and inquest processes take too long, the senior officers will all have moved on by the time the bell tolls for accountability time?
Awarded the President’s Medal, by
the Royal College of Psychiatrists.
Winner of the Mind Digital Media Award

All opinions expressed are my own – they do not represent the views of any organisation.
(c) Michael Brown, 2026
I am not a police officer.
I try to keep this blog up to date, but inevitably over time, amendments to the law as well as court rulings and other findings from inquests and complaints processes mean it is difficult to ensure all the articles and pages remain current. Please ensure you check all legal issues in particular and take appropriate professional advice where necessary.
Government legislation website – www.legislation.gov.uk